The 5 Best Sandwiches in Saint Paul

The 5 Best Sandwiches in Saint Paul

Put these five mouthwatering sandwiches on your must-try list today.

By Adam Johnson

I always hate reading "Best of" lists because, inherently, someone or something gets left out.  I don't think it is possible to have all encompassing knowledge on a given subject - especially food - as I have not experienced every possible sandwich in Saint Paul.

So first off, my disclaimer, I have not tasted every sandwich in Saint Paul and there's a good chance there is another one or two out there that should be on this list.   However, having lived in the Capital City for most of my life and having worked at Visit Saint Paul for over nine years, I have established a pretty solid body of work when it comes to dining in Saint Paul establishments.

So without further ado, I give you my "Five Best Sandwiches in Saint Paul" (in no particular order):  

Philly Cheese Steak | Goody's Hot City Pizza & Subs | $8.49*

The Philly Cheese Steak at Goody's Hot City PizzaThis has to be the best Philly outside of, well, Philadelphia. I can't remember what drew me into this little shop for the first time on the corner of Randolph and West 7th but I'm glad it happened.  I ordered the Philly on day one and have never waivered since, however, I have made one adjustment to my order. Your straight up Philly comes on a fresh Italian hoagie topped with melted Pepper Jack cheese, mushrooms, onion and green peppers. (you can hold any of those if you want)  The sandwich is always hot, fresh and mouthwatering and that magic cheese sauce is indescribably good.  The only thing I do special is ask them to "press it" a little to get a little of the grease out.  I guess it's my way of convincing myself I'm eating healthy.  The sandwich comes with chips which serve as a great landing spot for any gooey cheese or meat that falls off the sandwich. Enjoy this masterpiece from Goody's Hot City, just don't throw away the pretty yellow basket it comes in..

French Dip | Skinner's | $8.75*

Skinner's is a great little dive bar on Randolph and Milton.  This sandwich rises above the rest on a menu filled with great sandwiches, competent burgers and AMAZING pizza.  The Skinner's French Dip includes thinly sliced and piping hot roast beef on an absurdly fresh hoagie bun, smothered in Swiss cheese and covered in onions. The sandwich comes cut in half with toothpicks holding each bulging half together.  The magical little cup of au jus makes dipping this sandwich a delight.   All of the sandwiches come with chips and a pickle spear but upgrades are available.  I always upgrade to onion rings because, well, I really like their onion rings.  Eat in or take out, this sandwich has never disappointed me.

Hot Italian | Patrick McGovern's | $11.00*

The Hot Italian falls under McGovern's Pub Sandwiches section of the menu.  I only know this because I looked on their website while writing this blog.  When I'm in the place, I never even look at the menu - not since I first ordered this sandwich.  The Hot Italian includes a spicy sausage patty (perfectly spicy for my tastes)  with sauteed onions and green peppers, topped with melted mozzarella and zesty marinanra all on a grilled (grilled is important) hoagie bun.  It is absolutely amazing.  All of their pub sandwiches come with your choice of french fries, potato salad, creamy cole slaw, low-fat cottage cheese, small salad, chips or fresh fruit (when available).  I've never waivered from the cole slaw as it is a refreshing balance to the spicy sandwich.  One bite of this sandwich and it will become your lunch time staple at McGovern's.

BLT(O) | Aroma's Cafe | Whole $6.35 Half $5.15* 

Aroma's is a little known cafe in downtown located in The Lowry Building.  I usually prefer a bit more meat to my sandwich as evidenced by the first three on this list but this BLT from Aroma's is amazing - and I don't even like tomatoes.  Also, I technically get the BLTO as I love onions and think they really make this a great sandwich.  The bread, wheat or Italian, is made daily and always fresh.  The tomatoes are thinly sliced and the bacon is always crisp and hot.  The lettuce, (I'm not sure how to brag on lettuce) has always been crisp too. All of this is tied together with their magic mayo sauce for a mouth-watering BLTO sandwich that is light but filling.  Grab one next time you're on the run in downtown Saint Paul.

Brisket Sammy | Revival Saint Paul | $12.00*

Revival is brand new in Saint Paul in the old Cheeky Monkey location on Selby.  I decided to check this place out and decided on the Brisket Sammy from an overall exciting menu.  Two healthy slices of perfectly cooked brisket resting beneath a tangy mustard slaw, pork rinds and b+b's (that's slang for bread + butter pickles) all between two perfectly crispy slices of Texas Toast.  In full disclosure, I haven't even eaten this entire sandwich yet as I was with co-workers and we decided to share three entrees - I almost reneged on the pact.  The sandwich comes with one of their amazing side dishes - I went with their mac & cheese but their candied yams were delicious too.  It is seriously a game changer and unlike any other sandwich I have eaten.  

*price subject to change​ on all sandwiches without notice.

Have a sandwich that you just love in Saint Paul? Let us know about it on Twitter, Facebook or Instagram with #MYSAINTPAUL.

Editor's Note:  Adam Johnson is Vice President of Marketing at Visit Saint Paul, tourism rube and lover of delicious sandwiches.

Goody’s Hot City Restaurants/Dining Goody’s Hot City
Patrick McGovern’s Pub Restaurants/Dining Patrick Mcgovern’s Pub